COUNCILLORS have scrapped a ban on HGVs using narrow residential roads at a huge new neighbourhood 24/7 despite more than 200 objections from residents.
South Gloucestershire Council spatial planning committee overturned a decision last month that would have kept restrictions on the times lorries and large delivery vans can drive through Ladden Garden Village in Yate, a development of more than 2,000 homes as well as industrial estates.
In April, a lower-ranking committee rejected a request from developers to remove a planning condition which says HGVs can only use roads on the estate from 7.30am to 6pm weekdays and 8pm to 2pm on Saturday, and never on Sunday or public holidays.
Because that went against officers’ advice to approve the application, it went up to the council’s top planning committee for the final say, and that has now thrown out the decision.
Although it opens the prospect of lorry movements around the clock, another condition means every new company that moves into a unit will have to get its delivery times and types of vehicle signed off by council officers.
Principal planning officer Charmian Eyre-Walker told the committee on Thursday, May 23, that this gave the local authority the control to assess any impact on residents and to spread HGV movements over a 24-hour period so they were not concentrated at any one time.
She said the timing restrictions on large vehicles, introduced by councillors last summer when they granted permission to allow more general industry because no businesses wanted to rent out the existing office space, were deterring more firms from moving in, such as those needing deliveries at night.
Ms Eyre-Walker said they also applied to all HGVs which were defined as over 3.5 tonnes and included “low-loaders, flatbeds and supermarket and other delivery vehicles” such as Amazon and Ocado.
She said the planning condition should be removed because it was not necessary or relevant as the 2023 change-of-use consent for more general industry would result in fewer vehicles, and that it was also unenforceable and unreasonable.
But Yate North ward Lib Dem Cllr Chris Willmore, who backed objections from 210 neighbours and the town council, told the meeting: “This isn’t about the small delivery vans under seven tonnes, it’s about HGVs, the big stuff."
She said lorries were forced onto the wrong side of the road because of 90-degree turns on the residential roads.
“HGVs’ lights at night will be straight into people’s houses,” Cllr Willmore said.
“The residents are deeply worried about HGVs coming along the narrow roads past their bedroom windows.”
Applicants BDW Trading’s planning agent Rachel Robinson said the condition limiting HGV times was “not lawful” because it did not meet the required tests under national planning policy.
She said it was added by councillors last year despite “clear and undisputed evidence” that the change in use from light to more general industry would result in fewer HGVs and other vehicles, so it was “illogical”.
Cllr John Bradbury (Labour, Bradley Stoke South) said he was reasonably satisfied that the condition could be removed while the other condition requiring approval of delivery times and vehicles by the council would remain in place and protect residents adequately.
Cllr Paul Hughes (Conservative, Bitton & Oldland Common) said: “If the committee turns this down, it will go to appeal undoubtedly.”
Members voted 6-0 in favour of scrapping the restrictions, with one abstention.
Comments: Our rules
We want our comments to be a lively and valuable part of our community - a place where readers can debate and engage with the most important local issues. The ability to comment on our stories is a privilege, not a right, however, and that privilege may be withdrawn if it is abused or misused.
Please report any comments that break our rules.
Read the rules here